Science behind dietary supplements & their affects

Every day, nearly half of all American adults take a dietary supplement—often in the form of a vitamin, mineral, herb, or amino acid. Many do so with the hope of protecting their long-term health or lowering their risk of chronic diseases, particularly heart disease. In total, Americans spend over $32 billion annually on more than 85,000 different supplement products.

Supplements are often marketed as safe, natural alternatives to prescription medications. But the assumption that they are always beneficial—or harmless—is not supported by current medical research.

Supplements and Heart Health: What the Research Says

Unlike pharmaceuticals, dietary supplements are not required to undergo rigorous testing to prove their safety or effectiveness before entering the market. While supplement manufacturers can legally claim their products "support" health, those claims are not required to be backed by solid evidence. This contributes to widespread confusion among consumers.

One of the most commonly used supplements for heart health is the daily multivitamin. However, large-scale, randomized clinical trials—the gold standard in medical research—have consistently shown that multivitamins do not reduce the risk of heart disease.

You can explore the evidence yourself through reliable government resources such as MedlinePlus Herbs and Supplements, which offers research-backed summaries for hundreds of dietary products.

Supplements That Show Limited Potential

Some supplements have shown modest benefits for managing certain heart disease risk factors such as high blood pressure or elevated cholesterol. However, even in these cases, the evidence is limited and must be weighed against potential risks.

Garlic

• Some studies suggest that garlic supplements may reduce blood pressure by up to 8% in individuals with hypertension.

• However, garlic can interact with medications, including anticoagulants like warfarin, increasing the risk of bleeding.

Red Yeast Rice

• Red yeast rice supplements may help lower cholesterol because they contain compounds chemically similar to statins.

• Product quality varies significantly. Some supplements contain too little of the active ingredient to be effective; others are contaminated with citrinin, a toxic compound linked to kidney damage.

Contamination and Safety Concerns

Contamination of dietary supplements is a growing concern. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), more than 500 supplements have been found to contain undeclared pharmaceutical ingredients. These include prescription-strength stimulants, steroids, antidepressants, and erectile dysfunction medications.

This is especially dangerous when supplements are taken alongside prescribed medications. For example, a man on nitrates for chest pain who unknowingly takes a supplement laced with sildenafil (Viagra) could experience a dangerous drop in blood pressure. These "natural" supplements often contain pharmaceutical-grade compounds without any label disclosure or dosage information.

When Supplement Use May Be Appropriate

Doctors may recommend specific supplements in cases of diagnosed deficiencies or specific medical conditions. These include:

• Vitamin D and calcium for bone health and osteoporosis prevention

• Iron for those with iron-deficiency anemia

• Vitamin B12 for individuals with absorption issues or dietary restrictions

In general, a well-balanced diet that includes fruits, vegetables, lean protein, healthy fats, and whole grains can meet most nutritional needs without the need for supplements.

Guidelines for Safer Supplement Use

For those considering supplements, the following practices are recommended:

• Use single-ingredient products. These are easier to evaluate for effectiveness and reduce the risk of unknown interactions or contamination.

• Consult your physician. Always inform your doctor about any supplements you take, especially if you are on prescription medications or have a chronic health condition.

• Look for third-party certifications. Reputable organizations like the United States Pharmacopeia (USP) and NSF International test supplements for identity, quality, strength, and purity. Products bearing these seals are more likely to meet safety standards.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Dietary supplements may seem like an easy solution for improving heart health, but the evidence shows that most products offer little to no benefit—and may introduce real risks when used improperly. For men concerned about cardiovascular health, the most effective strategy remains a combination of a balanced diet, regular physical activity, and appropriate medical care.

With Bastion Health get expert guidance, virtual care, and tools to help improve your overall health—all covered through your employer.